Texas is legally required to educate every child who walks into a classroom, treat every patient who comes through an emergency room door, and answer every 911 call. What it doesn’t have is a consistent way to tell taxpayers what that costs.

A new research paper by TPPF’s Selene Rodriguez examines how illegal immigration affects Texas schools, hospitals, and first responders, and how little the state actually knows about it.

Start with healthcare. Under an executive order by Gov. Greg Abbott, Texas hospitals reported 313,742 visits by patients illegally present in the U.S. in fiscal year 2025, accounting for more than $1 billion in total healthcare costs. That is likely an undercount because patients can decline to answer the citizenship question, and no one verifies the answers.

Effective education policy relies on demographic data, whether it’s for low-income students, English learners, or students with special disabilities. This data is used to identify needs, and measure outcomes. Illegal alien children often face unique challenges that require targeted support. Yet no Texas state agency tracks student immigration status, so no one knows how many illegal aliens are enrolled in Texas classrooms.

The same pressure hits first responders. Undercounted population estimates make it difficult for local governments to accurately forecast demand. Imagine calling 911 and being put on hold, or told that responders would not be available any time soon. Kinney County (population ~3,000) saw EMS calls jump from about 235 a year to 486 in just the first ten months of 2022. Eagle Pass added an ambulance just to keep up.

Rodriguez offers a practical fix, and it doesn’t require relitigating Plyler v. Doe, which doesn’t prohibit tracking and reporting. The paper recommends that the Texas Education Agency create a statewide reporting framework, that the Legislature make GA-46’s hospital data collection permanent in statute, and that Texas expand EMS reporting to capture uncompensated costs and changes in call volume.

“Texas can’t manage what it doesn’t measure,” Rodriguez says. “Our schools, hospitals, and first responders are absorbing real costs every day, and policymakers deserve accurate numbers, not guesswork.”

Whatever your view on immigration, you can’t budget for, plan around, or fix a problem you refuse to count. It’s time for Texas to stop governing blind.

 

This commentary is published on Thursdays as part of TPPF’s subscriber-only newsletter that rounds up content from the week. Subscribe to The Post >>